What is behind the firings? Foreign workers are expensive, but they work better than Hungarians

By RockedBuzz 8 Min Read

The occasions of the previous few weeks may very well be seen as one-off instances, but in actuality nobody is aware of what number of occasions Hungarian workers are despatched after firms have recruited foreigners

– he stated when requested by Portfolio Imre Palkovics, president of the National Association of Workers’ Councils.

According to the owner-manager of Jobtain HR Service Kft., Magdolna Mihályi overseas firms investing in Hungary can make use of residents of their very own nation on secondment in Hungary, for one undertaking at a time, till they construct a plant and begin manufacturing. That is why we are able to meet, amongst others, workers of Chinese, Korean, and infrequently Turkish nationality. Dávid Maier, managing director of Terendo highlighted that visitor workers are primarily typical of educated workers in the manufacturing and processing industries in Hungary. Qualified labor is additionally wanted for development trade investments. In addition, workers from third nations are additionally being recruited in catering, logistics and cleansing.

The Hungarian worker works till he reaches the age of 65 after which retires. Foreigners work like there is no tomorrow.

– perceived one in every of the causes for the distinction in perspective between the Hungarian and Asian workforce Zoltán Karsai, president of the Commercial Employees Trade Union. “There are foreigners in the commerce, but not in giant numbers. However, there is little details about how a lot cash they work for. It is sure that their willingness to work time beyond regulation is very excessive. Their work ethic is very excessive,” he responded to Portfolio’s inquiry Zoltán Karsai, president of the Commercial Employees Trade Union. There are occasional Mongolian and Filipino workers in the outlets, but much more so in different areas of commerce. At a logistics web site, the wage system needed to be reformed as a result of the Filipino workers labored terribly exhausting and really rapidly reached the “prime of the prime pay.” He highlighted:

Therefore, the firm needed to develop a brand new compensation system in order that it will not trigger rigidity between the Hungarian and Asian workforce.

According to Dávid Maier, this is usually true. According to the supervisor of an organization specializing in labor mediation in Asia, the foremost purpose why home employers select them is not solely the labor scarcity, but additionally the decrease turnover fee and, in some instances, the greater productiveness and adaptability of overseas workers. “It is a false impression that is spreading increasingly more amongst the public {that a} overseas employee is cheaper than a Hungarian one. When an employer is eager about using overseas workers, it is not a straightforward determination. It is usually dearer for a Hungarian employer to make use of overseas workers, since there are many further prices additionally arises, which is not the case with home workers,” defined Maier.

At one in every of the earlier occasions of the Hungarian Economic Society Tamás Horváth, proprietor of the Menton Jobs labor rent firm expressed an analogous opinion: opposite to the often-heard opinions, Asian labor is not cheaper than Hungarian labor, in actual fact it is dearer, as a result of the bills associated to their importation and lodging, in addition to the administrative prices arising in reference to labor importation, should even be taken into consideration.

In reality, in comparison with Hungarian workers, we are speaking about 10-20 p.c dearer labor of their case. This 10-20 p.c further value is compensated for by the undeniable fact that the productiveness of the imported Asian visitor workers is 20-30 p.c greater than that of their colleagues working there earlier than

Tamás Horváth remarked.

Magdolna Mihályi, owner-manager of Jobtain HR Service Kft taking a look at the traits, he reported that in the first half of 2023 there was the next quantity of labor imports, a major slowdown was skilled in the second half of the 12 months. “It is a false impression that foreigners could be employed for a decrease wage. Foreign workers are additionally topic to Hungarian laws on the labor market. At a given firm, each Hungarian and overseas workers obtain the identical wages for the identical job. The guidelines of equal remedy outlined in the Labor Code and the in response to the wage desk in impact at the given borrower or employer, the staff obtain it relying on the place. This additionally applies to the quantity of time beyond regulation and shift allowance,” he stated.

Imre Palkovics additionally highlighted that using overseas workers has many prices. “The firm not solely undertakes to pay the wages, but additionally pays for the aircraft ticket and lodging.

At the identical time, if an organization has to downsize, then, in response to expertise, it prefers to ship the educated Hungarian employee

– he emphasised. According to him, this ought to be prevented. According to the National Association of Workers’ Councils, the regulation ought to be tightened in order that whoever dismisses a Hungarian worker can not rent new overseas workers for six months.

“We should not assume that in India, Vietnam or the Philippines the wage for a educated place is ten occasions greater than in Hungary. Or that these folks will come to work for pennies or a bowl of rice. They come primarily to have the ability to earn and save considerably extra money than of their residence nation,” stated Dávid Maier, managing director of Terendo.

In South India, for instance, the common salaries in apprenticeship positions vary between HUF 60,000 and HUF 100,000 internet. Therefore, for the wage, they work comparable hours as in Hungary, he added. And if these folks go overseas, they is not going to solely go away their nation and household for a couple of tens of 1000’s of forints extra, and go to work in a distant and rather more costly place. Their major aim is to ship most of their wage residence to their households – defined Dávid Maier, who says that this is additionally why they do not work cheaper than the Hungarians. “An employer will need to have a great provide for the overseas worker. It should compete with European nations in addition to the alternatives supplied by Middle Eastern nations,” he concluded.

Cover picture supply: Shutterstock

Share This Article
Leave a comment