Alejandro Garnacho vs Wayne Rooney: Which overhead kick was better?

William of England
By William of England 6 Min Read
origin 1

By Euan Burns

Alejandro Garnacho could have already secured the Premier League Goal of the Season award for 2023/24.

The Argentine winger’s overhead kick within the opening minutes in opposition to Everton despatched Manchester United in direction of a objectiveimportant victory which many did not assume they might get, given the outpouring of anger and dedication inside Goodison Park following the factors deduction.

Naturally, the talk instantly sparked on-line as as to if this was the best objective or top-of-the-line ever within the Premier League. Let’s not get into this matter now, however there may be one other debate that must be opened: what is best, Garnacho in opposition to Everton or Wayne Rooney in opposition to Manchester City?

Analyze Garnacho’s overhead kick in opposition to Everton

Let’s begin by trying on the alternative. This was a Premier League match at a time when Manchester United want each level they will get. The Red Devils could have been the in-form crew within the Championship, however they did not really feel prefer it and something aside from a win would have led to speak of a disaster once more.

Furthermore, it was a visit to Goodison Park, one of the hostile environments within the nation for an away crew. Add that Manchester crew and the massive protests and wave of noise within the early levels because of the factors deduction, and it was an surroundings wherein many gamers would have chosen to play safely. Man Utd would have been entitled to attempt to climate any early storm and drive their manner into the sport.

Instead, Garnacho noticed the ball coming from Diogo Dalot on the fitting and shortly took 4 steps again and steadied himself, realizing what he was about to aim. As for the precise method, he’s unchallenged within the space, however the connection is the sweetest you may think about. It is actually flawless.

It hits the highest nook with energy, and Jordan Pickford’s makes an attempt to clear his goal are futile. Contextually, it was precisely what Man Utd wanted and, technically, it was a perfect overhead kick.

Let’s analyze Rooney’s overhead kick in opposition to Manchester City

While we have outlined the problem of the event when Garnacho scored his overhead kick, Rooney’s 2011 one in all probability takes the cake. This was a Manchester derby, across the time that Manchester City had change into able to beating Manchester Utd to the league title.

Manchester City had been within the working for the title Manchester United and Arsenal at this level, with simply over 10 video games to play. David Silva’s equalizer canceled out Nani’s opener and it regarded like Sir Alex Ferguson’s aspect would find yourself at Old Trafford. In the 78th minute, nevertheless, Rooney stepped up and had a go, as all elite strikers do. The win was key to Man Utd opening a niche on the prime of the desk throughout that weekend in February and successful the Premier League.

From a technical and aesthetic standpoint there are a few issues with Rooney’s objective. It appears ridiculous to say this as a result of it is one of many biggest targets ever scored, however right here we’re. The manner Nani’s cross is deflected off the defender’s again takes one thing away visually. Secondly, as Manchester City followers wish to level out, there’s a contact of shin to Rooney’s reference to the ball.

The energy with which the ball hit the again of the web was merely astonishing and is rightly considered one of many biggest targets ever scored within the Premier League.

The verdict

Overall, then, Rooney takes into consideration the event of the match and its significance within the context of a season. If Man Utd now win all their video games for the rest of the 2023/24 season, maybe they could possibly be confronted once more, however the “Manchester derby in a title race” triumphs “away to Everton in November”.

That mentioned, Garnacho nonetheless scored in a extremely troublesome scenario for Man Utd. Everyone knew an early objective could possibly be essential at Goodison Park, given the context, and he supplied it. Besides that, the method appears to be cleaner. There is totally no suggestion that he took the shot, and it was additionally farther from the goal, which meant he wanted to generate extra energy.

Furthermore, the build-up to the ball arriving with him within the field was smoother than for Rooney’s objective. Therefore, an govt choice was made that Garnacho’s overhead kick in opposition to Everton was: As quickly as, higher than Rooney’s in opposition to Manchester City. Don’t let this make you overlook how good Rooney was.


This article was initially revealed on as Alejandro Garnacho vs Wayne Rooney: Which overhead kick was better?.

Share This Article
Leave a comment